Daily Star :: Can Yunus create a poverty free world?
Gaziul Hasan Khan looks at the options in the Nobel laureate's new book
Published On: 2008-05-10
Creating a World Without Poverty
- Muhammad Yunus
Subarna
Nobel Peace laureate Professor Muhammad Yunus, a pioneer of collateral free small credit to poor women, is in quest of harnessing free market power to solve the problems of poverty, hunger and inequality across the world. Grameen Bank, which he founded more than three decades ago to reach collateral free credit to the target group at their doorstep, has been replicated in all the continents to benefit over 100 million families. But he remains far from satisfied as poverty, hunger and inequality continue to trouble the world as well as his native Bangladesh. If the dynamics of capitalism could be applied properly, he believes, poverty, the greatest challenge, facing mankind, could be tackled to a great extent.
This precisely is the subject matter of Creating a World Without
Poverty, his much talked about book, published recently. Originally
published by the Public Affairs, a New York based publisher, it was
reprinted in Dhaka by Subarna in February. According to the publishers,
Prof. Yunus, in his book, has gone beyond microcredit, to pioneer the
idea of "Social Business", or use the creative vibrancy of business to
tackle problems, ranging from poverty to pollution, inadequate
health-care to lack of education. In the 248-page book, the banker to
the poor discusses how the concept of social business could be relevant
for the ignored in a capitalist global economy, where the lone mantra
is to maximize profit.
"To make the structure of capitalism complete," he stresses, "we need
to introduce another kind of business one that recognizes the
multidimensional nature of human being. If we describe our existing
companies as profit-maximizing businesses (PMBs), the new kind of
business might be called social business." He calls for breaking new
grounds, so that, "entrepreneurs will set up social businesses not to
achieve limited personal gain but to pursue specific social goals".
Not a dogmatic free marketeer, the author thinks that no harm would be
done if not all businesses were for maximizing profit. Surely, he
argues, capitalism is amenable to improvements. The stakes, "are too
high," thinks an apprehensive Yunus, if the world goes on the way it
has been going to create a world that "ignores the multidimensional
nature of human beings," and business remains incapable of addressing
the social problems.
The emergence of capitalism three centuries ago, he recognizes, made it
possible for man to achieve an unprecedented material progress. In the
last two decades or so, the free market economy has taken roots in many
regions of the world, including China, post-Soviet Russia, Eastern
Europe and much of South America. North America and Western Europe
achieved many extraordinary things, including unprecedented wealth,
using free market and capitalism as tools. But the great success, he
thinks, could not keep away a pervasive sense of disillusionment that
is setting in, as the existing system of capitalism in no way benefits
a vast majority of the world's population. He does not doubt that
global trade is booming and the multinational corporations find good
reasons to spread out to every corner of the planet.
But all this cannot ignore the stark reality that ninety-four per cent
of the world's earnings goes to 40 per cent of the people, requiring
the other 60 percent to live on 6 percent. The reality that 50 percent
of the global population lives on two dollars or less a day and a
billion live on less than even one dollar a day gives Yunus reason to
think of 'social business'. Poverty is pervasive across the world,
though not distributed evenly, with some regions having more of it.
Even in the US, the richest country on earth, social progress has been
disappointing. After two decades of slow global progress to reduce
poverty, the number of people living in poverty is again on the rise.
No wonder, almost a generation after the Cold War came to an end, Yunus
has to cry out for an ever elusive "peace dividend" and campaign for
cutting defense spending to use the funds for addressing poverty.
Since the year 2000, when world leaders gathered at the UN to set the
goal of reducing poverty by half by 2015, the results remain
disappointing. Many observers of the global scenario remain sceptical,
with half the time gone, that the Millennium Development Goals can at
all be achieved. What's wrong? Yunus thinks that market economy, in its
current form, instead of solving social problems, could actually
aggravate poverty, inequality, corruption, crime, pollution and
diseases.
But instead of losing heart, he thinks globalization, more than any
other system, can bring benefits to the poor. But that would require
proper oversight and guidelines. Otherwise globalization has the
potential to be destructive. He calls for the replacement of the norm,
"the strongest takes all", by more humane rules to ensure that even the
poorest can use the highway. Otherwise, the global free market will be
a tool to benefit only 'financial imperialism'. The market, whether it
is local, national or regional, also needs to come under reasonable
rules and control to protect the interests of the poor. Governments can
do much to address social problems. But politics sometimes stands in
the way of their efficiency. Despite all difficulties, a government
must do its part to alleviate poverty. But no government alone can
solve all the problems, he thinks.
Many people who care about the problems of the poor, out of frustration
with governments, took the initiative to launch nonprofit
organizations, he writes. But he thinks this 'no profit' approach alone
has proved to be an inadequate response to social problems. Worsening
global poverty and the consequent problems, faced by people, prove
beyond doubt that charity by itself cannot solve the problem.
Multilateral institutions, sponsored and funded by governments to
eliminate poverty, have not achieved much either, he observes.
Social business, he suggests, needs to be different in terms of
objectives alone, to focus totally on solving social and environment
problems. But its organizational structure would be the same as that of
other businesses. He predicts that 'social business' will be a familiar
fixture on the global business stage. Prof Yunus is only seeking to
give capitalism a new, humane face.
Multilateral institutions like the World Bank, he points out, consider
growth in gross domestic product (GDP) as synonymous to poverty
elimination, for which hundreds of billons of dollars they have spent
have proved to be counterproductive. Prof. Yunus puts forward a
sevenpoint program for a new World Bank approach in funding governments
as well as private sector investors, to channelize investment through
his model of social business.
Yunus does not hesitate to show how the existing practice of corporate
social responsibility, built on good intentions, is misused by
corporate leaders as nothing more than window dressing to achieve
selfish benefits for their companies. Without "social business", he
argues, existing capitalism will continue to function with its half
developed structure, taking a narrow view of human nature, on the
erroneous assumption that man is a one-dimensional entity, concerned
with nothing other than the pursuit of a maximization of profits.
The concept of the existing system of free market, as generally
understood, is based on this single dimension. Yunus also points out
that the mainstream free market theory suffers from a
"conceptualization failure", a failure to take into consideration the
essence of what it is to be human. Here he has no two opinions with
Oscar Wilde --- "they know the price of everything and the value of
nothing."
Gaziul Hasan Khan is former Chief Editor and Managing Director of the national news agency Bangladesh Sangbad Sangstha .
Url: http://www.thedailystar.net/story.php?nid=35747
|